AN OUR KIDS REPORT:Columbia International College vs. St. Mildred's-Lightbourn School

one-to-one comparison:

View Columbia International College's full report
VS.
View St. Mildred's-Lightbourn School's full report

  • SCHOOL LOCATION

    Distance From

    Map

    Address

    Address

    1003 Main Street West, Hamilton, Ontario, L8S 4P3, Canada

    1080 Linbrook Road, Oakville, Ontario, L6J 2L1, Canada

  • SCHOOL OVERVIEW

    Basics

    Basics

    Founded

    1979

    1891

    Enrolment

    1700

    550

    Grades

    9 to 12

    JK to 12

    Gender

    Coed

    Girls

    Living arrangements

    Day, Boarding

    Day

    Language of instruction

    English

    English

    Faith Based

    School focus

    Academic

    Academic

    Developmental Priorities

    Balanced
    Equal emphasis is placed on a balance of priorities: intellectual, emotional, social and physical cultivation.
    Balanced
    Equal emphasis is placed on a balance of priorities: intellectual, emotional, social and physical cultivation.
    Intellectual
    The goal is to cultivate "academically strong, creative and critical thinkers, capable of exercising rationality, apprehending truth, and making aesthetic distinctions."
    Balanced
    Equal emphasis is placed on a balance of priorities: intellectual, emotional, social and physical cultivation.

    Academics

    Academics

    Curriculum

    Traditional

    Progressive, Reggio Emilia

    Curriculum pace

    Standard-enriched
    Broadly-speaking, the main curriculum -- like that of most schools -- paces the provincially-outlined one. This pace is steady and set by the teachers and school. The curriculum might still be enriched in various ways: covering topics more in-depth and with more vigor than the provincial one, or covering a broader selection of topics.
    Standard-enriched
    Broadly-speaking, the main curriculum -- like that of most schools -- paces the provincially-outlined one. This pace is steady and set by the teachers and school. The curriculum might still be enriched in various ways: covering topics more in-depth and with more vigor than the provincial one, or covering a broader selection of topics.

    Academic culture

    Rigorous
    A school with a “rigorous” academic culture places a high value on academic performance, and expects their students to do the same. This does not mean the school is uncaring, unsupportive, or non-responsive -- far from it. A school can have a rigorous academic culture and still provide excellent individual support. It does mean, however, the school places a particular emphasis on performance -- seeking the best students and challenging them to the fullest extent -- relative to a normal baseline. High expectations and standards – and a challenging yet rewarding curriculum – are the common themes here. Keep in mind this classification is more relevant for the older grades: few Kindergarten classrooms, for example, would be called “rigorous”.
    Rigorous
    A school with a “rigorous” academic culture places a high value on academic performance, and expects their students to do the same. This does not mean the school is uncaring, unsupportive, or non-responsive -- far from it. A school can have a rigorous academic culture and still provide excellent individual support. It does mean, however, the school places a particular emphasis on performance -- seeking the best students and challenging them to the fullest extent -- relative to a normal baseline. High expectations and standards – and a challenging yet rewarding curriculum – are the common themes here. Keep in mind this classification is more relevant for the older grades: few Kindergarten classrooms, for example, would be called “rigorous”.

    Avg. Class Size

    12 to 22

    Varies

    Special needs support

    Gifted learner support

    In-class adaptations

    Dedicated gifted school

    Preschool/K curriculum

    Reggio Emilia
    Reggio Emilia programs aim to develop curiosity and problem-solving skills through the liberal use of “projects”, (as opposed to “activities” or “lessons”). Teachers design projects for children around their demonstrated interests. Projects can be geared to an individual student, a small group of students, or the class as a whole. Projects can last from a few days to the whole year. Art is strongly emphasized and is typically incorporated into every project. Teachers actively participate in projects alongside students, rather than sitting back and observing. A high degree of parent involvement is also encouraged, particularly when forming curriculums and project plans (which happens throughout the academic year).
    If you want to learn more about Reggio Emilia education, check out our comprehensive guide.

    Tuition

    Tuition

    Day Tuition

    $25,180 to $32,310

    Boarding Tuition

    $3,000

    Financial aid (FA)

    No

    Yes

    Students on FA

    0%

    9%

    Eligible grades for FA

    None

    None

    Median FA package size

    $0

    $0

    Enrollment

    Enrollment

    Avg. enrollment per grade

    425

    37

    Percent in boarding

    100%

    0%

    Admissions

    Admissions

    Admissions rate

    86%

    74%

    Day entry years

    7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

    Preschool, JK, SK, K, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

    Boarding entry years

    7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

    Day admissions deadline

    Rolling

    Oct 31, 2021

    Boarding admissions deadline

    Rolling

    Not available

    Interview required?

    No

    Yes: grades Preschool - 12

    SSAT required

    No

    No

  • OUR PERSPECTIVE

    The Our Kids Review

    The Our Kids Review

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    While some schools pride themselves on being small, Columbia finds its strength in being large—with a student population in excess of 1800, it is easily the largest boarding school in Canada. What Columbia might lack in intimacy it gains in the ability to provide a wealth of supports and programs that smaller schools simply can't. The school maintains extensive liaison offices, a dedicated guidance staff, and even its own medical clinic. The faculty, through size and experience, is remarkably adept at providing a quality, well-rounded education with an eye to success in postsecondary education. The school provides ESL to students who need it, and liaises directly with universities in Canada and beyond in order to facilitate the transition to postsecondary education. In all, the school excels at doing what it was created to do: to support the university-bound international learner who is living away from home within a culture, and at times a language, that is unfamiliar.
    Read The Our Kids Review of Columbia International College

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    “St. Mildred’s-Lightbourn School has grown and evolved into a place where girls can forge their unique educational paths in a caring, close-knit community.” “At SMLS, every aspect of students’ experience – whether it’s math class, basketball practice, debate club or lunch in the dining hall – is carefully constructed to be part of their growth and learning.” “The students and parents we spoke to, who were from diverse cultural backgrounds, said the school works hard to live up to its aspirations on equity, diversity, and inclusion.”
    Read The Our Kids Review of St. Mildred's-Lightbourn School

    Our Take

    Our Take

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    While some schools pride themselves on being small, Columbia finds its strength in being large—with a student population in excess of 1800, it is easily the largest boarding school in Canada. What Columbia might lack in intimacy it gains in the ability to provide a wealth of supports and programs that smaller schools simply can't. The school maintains extensive liaison offices, a dedicated guidance staff, and even its own medical clinic. The faculty, through size and experience, is remarkably adept at providing a quality, well-rounded education with an eye to success in postsecondary education. The school provides ESL to students who need it, and liaises directly with universities in Canada and beyond in order to facilitate the transition to postsecondary education. In all, the school excels at doing what it was created to do: to support the university-bound international learner who is living away from home within a culture, and at times a language, that is unfamiliar.

    View full report

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    The school has a long history, having been founded in Toronto 1891. After a move to Oakville, it later paired with a school guided by Ruth Lightbourn, a renowned teacher who founded a school almost by default—she began as a tutor for the children of John Guest, then headmaster of Appleby College, and her success was of the kind we associate with Nanny McPhee. She became the go-to tutor, and in time founded her own school. That and St. Mildred's formally joined in 1969, combining the traditions and the drive of both under one umbrella. More than anything, the intention is to provide girls with the skills, experience, and esteem that will carry over into academic and professional success. Ample opportunities are provided for students to discover their passions, wherever they may lie, as well as the encouragement to grow within those areas of interest.

    View full report
  • School’s perspective

    Who are you, as a school?

    Who are you, as a school?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    "Columbia International College is Canada’s largest private boarding school, offering Grades 9 to 12 programs. Our Total Care Education System® ensures that every student’s academic, social, emotional and physical needs are tended to. We are #1 in offers of admission from the University of Toronto, University of Waterloo and McMaster University. We are also #1 in scholarships awarded by universities. We offer the only official University of Toronto partnership program - the Elite Pathway Partnership Program."

    • Canada's largest boarding school
    • Total Care Education System® - Total Learning, Total Living, Total Development, Total Communication
    • Offers Grade 9-12 , ESL, and Summer Camp, Short-term/Exchange programs
    • Offer the only official University of Toronto partnership program - the Elite Pathway
    • Leadership programming and The Duke of Edinburgh award ( Bronze, Silver and Gold)
    • University Partners® provide exclusive scholarships to graduates
    • University of Toronto's official Global Partner School
    • # 1 in university admissions and scholarships among all high schools in Canada
    • Separate residences for boys and girls with door-to-door school bus transportation
    • Official Test Centre for IELTS

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    "SMLS students (JK to 12) benefit from an enriched academic and co-curricular program, personalized learning, unique Signature Programs, world class facilities and teachers who are experts in educating girls. We engage each student in a personalized, real-world learning experience—one where she can explore her own unique pathways within a nurturing community. From the moment a student enters SMLS, she begins a journey of discovery to emerge empowered and ready to achieve excellence in whatever path she chooses."

    • Signature Programs in Global Citizenship, STEM & Robotics, Active Healthy Living, Arts & Design
    • Professional Internship Customized for Each Girl (Grade 11)
    • Focus on whole girl and student wellbeing
    • Enriched curriculum, Advanced Placement, DELF
    • Beautiful 10-acre campus in the heart of Oakville
    • Bus routes servicing the geographic regions in Halton, Peel and Toronto
    • World-class facilities, including fitness & yoga studios, soundproof music studios, theatre & more
    • Financial Aid

    Array

    What do you do differently and uniquely well?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    "What differentiates SMLS from all the other schools are the fact that we are experts in personalization. We offer a large school experience with all of the same academic opportunities, athletics, co-curriculars and success, but with a tight-knit, small-school feel, where we’re all part of a community that cares and is connected to one another."

    Array

    What tradeoffs has your school made to serve families in this way?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Information not available

    Array

    What key junctures in your school's history have most shaped its present?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Information not available

    Array

    What type of student is a good fit for your school?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Information not available

    Array

    Under what conditions would you advise a family against choosing your school?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Information not available

    Array

    To your knowledge, why do families choose your school over others?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    "Families seek out an SMLS experience for the opportunities the school provides their daughters. As an all-girls school that prioritizes both academic excellence and personal wellbeing, parents know that their daughters are developing in a safe, nurturing environment - one where students get to know themselves and take risks in a safe, comfortable way.

    Families who have been at SMLS comment time and again about the warmth and strong sense of community that exists across the school."

    Array

    How would you characterize your school's image amongst the public?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Information not available

    Array

    What aspect of your school is underappreciated?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    "Families are often surprised and impressed by the fact that we have leadership opportunities for every student, starting even in the Junior School and as early as Grade 1.There are ways for every student, whether they’re an introvert or an extravert, whether they have many interests or just one passion - whether they’re an athlete, an artist, an academic or still working on finding themselves - every student has an opportunity to lead."

    Array

    What might families find surprising about your school?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    "SMLS is an Anglican-based that welcomes students from every faith, fostering diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging within our
    school community. Our weekly chapels celebrate both our Anglican roots and world religions and cultures so that everyone in our community may develop an understanding of the diversity in the world around us."

    Array

    What improvements or changes has your school made recently?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Information not available

    Array

    How will your school change in the next 5 years?

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Information not available

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Information not available

  • SCHOOL LEADERSHIP

    Message from school leadership

    Message from school leadership

    Welcome!

    As Principal of Columbia International College, my belief is that in order for your children to be successful as international students, they need to be cared for as if they were at home with you. All my teachers and staff share the same belief.

    The need for students to learn in an environment where they are well supported is the chief concern that thousands upon thousands of parents have shared with us over the years. From its beginning in 1979, CIC was built to address this concern. We wanted to make sure that every international student could study in a fully supported environment of caring: academically, socially, emotionally and physically.

    We created an approach that would do just that – look after the whole child around the clock. We call it the Total Care Education System®. It’s a study environment where the academic program, the staff and the facilities are fully integrated as one – all geared towards helping students achieve success and give parents peace of mind.

    After almost 40 years, we are proud of how well our Total Care approach works. Our students are most successful in getting admitted to some of the world’s best universities and receiving admission scholarships. Our consistent, proven track record has gained the confidence among parents from over 100 countries.

    But most important to me, it’s how the students have achieved success: in a supportive environment, one where they can study in health, safety and happiness and where their parents can be fully confident that they are being cared for.

    Columbia International College can make the difference in how your child can go higher with their future: positively building their character and helping them to be responsible, global citizens. Through our brochure and website, you can learn more about how Total Care Education System provides peace of mind for parents and fosters success for students.

    If you have any questions about our approach, please reach out to me personally at [email protected].

    Thank you for your interest in St. Mildred’s-Lightbourn School. 

    It is a great privilege and honour to be the Head of School at St. Mildred's-Lightbourn School. I am delighted to be a part of the school's warm and invitational learning community with such a longstanding and rich heritage of more than129 years.  SMLS is an all-girls learning environment where girls are encouraged to discover and pursue their personal excellence through a rigorous academic program. Our faculty and staff are deeply committed and dedicated to preparing girls for a strong inspired future as empowered young women. 

    The entire community celebrates our recent graduates, all of whom are anticipating the start of the next phase of their journey at Canadian and international universities of their choice. For those families who are considering St. Mildred's-Lightbourn School for their daughter, there are a number of virtual opportunities for you to connect and get to know the school, where you will be warmly welcomed.    

    Nancy

  • EXTRACURRICULARS

    Competitive

    Comp.

    Recreational

    Rec.

    Competitive

    Comp.

    Recreational

    Rec.

    Badminton

    Baseball

    Basketball

    Canoeing/Kayaking

    Cricket

    Cross-country skiing

    Cycling

    Downhill skiing

    Equestrian

    Fencing

    Field Hockey

    Figure Skating

    Football

    Golf

    Gymnastics

    Ice Hockey

    Ice Skating

    Lacrosse

    Martial Arts

    Mountain biking

    Racquet Ball

    Rowing

    Rugby

    Running

    Sailing

    Skateboarding

    Snowboarding

    Soccer

    Softball

    Squash

    Swimming

    Tennis

    Track & Field

    Volleyball

    Weightlifting

    Wrestling

    Archery

    Curling

    Ultimate


    Clubs Offered

    Clubs offered

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Ballet and Classical Ballet
    Yoga
    Yearbook
    Student Council
    Scouting
    Science Club
    School newspaper
    Round Square
    Robotics club
    Radio club
    Poetry/Literature club
    Photography
    Paintball
    Outdoor Education
    Outdoor Club
    Online Magazine
    Musical theatre/Opera
    Math Club
    Jazz Ensemble
    Habitat for Humanity
    Foreign Language Club
    Environmental Club
    Drama Club
    Debate Club
    Dance Club
    Computer Club
    Community Service
    Choir
    Chess Club
    Band
    Audiovisual Club
    Astronomy Club
    Art Club
    Animation

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Ballet and Classical Ballet
    Yoga
    Yearbook
    Student Council
    Scouting
    Science Club
    School newspaper
    Round Square
    Robotics club
    Radio club
    Poetry/Literature club
    Photography
    Paintball
    Outdoor Education
    Outdoor Club
    Online Magazine
    Musical theatre/Opera
    Math Club
    Jazz Ensemble
    Habitat for Humanity
    Foreign Language Club
    Environmental Club
    Drama Club
    Debate Club
    Dance Club
    Computer Club
    Community Service
    Choir
    Chess Club
    Band
    Audiovisual Club
    Astronomy Club
    Art Club
    Animation


    What the school says

    What the school says

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    • We run multiple varsity teams, including basket ball, soccer, badminton, table tennis, and dance.
    • 90+ clubs and extracurricular activities for students
    • School Club Fair is held twice a year where students can learn more about, and register for, extracurricular activities.
    • We have a very robust and highly competitive intramural program(Basket ball, soccer, badminton, and table tennis).
    • We have a competitive Model United Nation team, competes internationally.
    • Every student completes leadership training in our tiered leadership program.
    • We provide the opportunity for students to participate in all levels of the Duke of Edinburgh's International Award Program. We offer weekly community service opportunities for our students to meaningfully give back to out local community. We provide options for students to fulfill all aspects of the Award, including the Adventure Journey.
    • We offer a dynamic weekend program with a variety of trips and activities.

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    • Internationally recognized Robotics program Competitive sports Robust arts offerings (drama, music, etc.)
  • Financial Aid

    Grades eligible

    Grades eligible

    Students on aid

    Students on aid

    0%

    9%

    Avg. aid package (annual)

    Avg. aid package (annual)

    $0

    $0

  • ADMISSIONS

    Admissions

    Admissions rate

    86%

    74%

    Day entry years

    7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

    Preschool, JK, SK, K, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

    Boarding entry years

    7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

    Day admissions deadline

    Rolling

    Oct 31, 2021

    Boarding admissions deadline

    Rolling

    Not available

    Interview required?

    No

    Yes: grades Preschool - 12

    SSAT required

    No

    No

    SSAT(out of province) required

    No

    No

    Entrance exams required

    Yes: grades 9 - 12

    Yes

    Entrance essay required

    No

    No

    Application fee required

    No

    No

    Type of student school is looking for

    Type of student school is looking for

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Students who are pursuing OSSD and post-secondary education.

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Students applying to SMLS should be prepared to participate in an enriched academic program that balances fundamental skill development with inquiry-based learning. SMLS offers a wide range of co-curricular opportunities and we encourage students to participate widely. Students who are most successful at SMLS are bright and engaged learners who are keen to get involved.

    What the school says

    What the school says

    COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE

    Students are asked to submit their transcripts from their previous school with their application form.

    ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL

    Please see our website: http://www.smls.on.ca/Page/Admissions

  • NOTABLE ALUMNI

    Alumni

    Alumnus (year)
    Accomplishment

    Roger Tong (1981)
    Roger Tong is AsiaSat’s Chief Executive Officer. Roger has over 30 yearsʼ experience in the satellite and telecommunications industry.
    Ken Seng Tan (1988)
    Dr. Ken Seng Tan is a prominent figure in the world of Actuarial Sciences, professor at the University of Waterloo and member of Canada’s Research Chair in Quantitative Risk Management.
    Sasha-Kay Gilzean (2002)
    Sasha-Kay is a member of the Honourable Society of the Inner Temple, the Bar Council (UK), the Jamaican Bar Association and the Law Society of Ontario.
    You Ming Tan (2007)
    You Ming Tan (谭佑铭) is a successful creative singer songwriter in China. In 2010, he won the 4th place in China’s Super Boy Singing Competition, a popular reality TV talent show in China.
    information not available

Compare:

COLUMBIA INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE:
THE OUR KIDS REPORT  

ST. MILDRED'S-LIGHTBOURN SCHOOL:
THE OUR KIDS REPORT  




x

By logging in or creating an account, you agree to Our Kids' Terms and Conditions. Information presented on this page may be paid advertising provided by the advertisers [schools/camps/programs] and is not warranted or guaranteed by OurKids.net or its associated websites. By using this website, creating or logging into an Our Kids account, you agree to Our Kids' Terms and Conditions. Please also see our Privacy Policy. Our Kids ™ © 2023 All right reserved.