Parents searching for the best private school naively consult school rankings such as those provided by the Fraser Institute and others. Even schools that are ranked well on such lists object to being ranked by external sources based on simplistic criteria. As one appalled school administrator has said, "[Families need to] go look at the school… look at behaviour during recess, look at how the kids respond to adults. For me, it's always about the child, the family and the fit." All school ranking lists are fundamentally shallow.
If used properly, school rankings can provide some helpful insight for parents as they search for the right school for their child(ren). Rankings on the basis of some factors, as provided below, can be useful for any of the following reasons:
Be skeptical about all school rankings (including those below). Consider their limitations. All rankings lists are superficial. They offer no hint whatsoever, of how well your child will like the school or how well he or she will thrive in a specific environment. Many kids fare very well in schools that do not perform well in rankings for university placement and other factors.
As a nominally useful tool, we look at some Quebec school rankings below. Use with caution. Our Kids offers much more helpful, worthwhile resources for parents including our detailed, richly researched advice guide, our singular Montreal private school expo, our in-depth school profiles, and much more. Any concern with rankings of "the best schools" should be tempered by a much greater focus on finding the right fit for your child(ren), and on diligently following through on a deeply considered school choice process.
Private schools with the lowest admission rates might seem to be the "best" to some parents because they are the hardest to get into. Acceptance rates are affected by a school's academic standards and the number of families who are applying, of course. However, there are other mitigating factors (such as schools' marketing budgets) that affect a school's popularity. And it's important to remember that many of the best private schools have high acceptance rates. In any case, parents should not place too much emphasis on this factor. It's more important to focus on how well their children will fit into a school and many other factors. Parents may find this list helpful to know if a school they have applied to is, in fact, more difficult to get into.
|1||Miss Edgar's & Miss Cramp's School||Westmount, QC||K to 11||49%|
|2||Pensionnat du Saint-Nom-de-Marie||Montreal, QC||7 to 11||50%|
|3||Priory School||Montreal, QC||K to 6||75%|
|4||Alexander von Humboldt German International School||Baie-D'Urfé, Montreal, QC||PS to 12||80%|
|5||North Star Academy||Laval, QC||7 to 12||86%|
|6||Académie Marie-Claire||Kirkland, QC||PS to 11||90%|
Parents seeking the most expensive private schools may naively feel that tuition cost is directly correlated to the quality of education offered. This is not necessarily true, in every case. Certainly, more expensive schools offer advantages such as some better facilities, some highly qualified instructors, a greater amount of extracurricular activities, etc. But there are many schools that charge very reasonable private school tuition rates, while producing some of the top graduates in Quebec. You need to focus your search on which school will be the best for your child(ren). Below we list Quebec private schools (restricted to those that list with ourkids.net) with the highest tuition rates.
|1||Bishop's College School||Sherbrooke, QC||7 to 12||$25,000|
|2||Study||Westmount, QC||K to 11||$20,140 to $22,675|
|3||Selwyn House School||Westmount, QC||K to 11||$17,500 to $22,500|
|4||Lower Canada College||Montreal, QC||K to 12||$17,625 to $22,485|
|5||Miss Edgar's & Miss Cramp's School||Westmount, QC||K to 11||$18,764 to $21,417|
|6||St. George's School of Montreal||Montreal, QC||K to 11||$17,390 to $21,217|
|7||Centennial Academy||Montreal, QC||7 to 11||$19,750|
|8||Priory School||Montreal, QC||K to 6||$16,475 to $18,690|
|9||Trafalgar School For Girls||Montreal, QC||7 to 11||$17,995|
|10||Académie Marie-Claire||Kirkland, QC||PS to 11||$14,094 to $16,910|
Find Quebec private schools ranked by founding date. There is some prestige to be found in older schools, certainly, but we urge you to judge schools on factors that are more pertinent to the overall wellbeing of your child(ren).
|1||Bishop's College School||Sherbrooke, QC||7 to 12||1836|
|2||Sacred Heart School of Montreal||Montreal, QC||7 to 12||1861|
|3||Trafalgar School For Girls||Montreal, QC||7 to 11||1887|
|4||Selwyn House School||Westmount, QC||K to 11||1901|
|5||Pensionnat du Saint-Nom-de-Marie||Montreal, QC||7 to 11||1905|
|6||Miss Edgar's & Miss Cramp's School||Westmount, QC||K to 11||1909|
|7||Lower Canada College||Montreal, QC||K to 12||1909|
|8||Study||Westmount, QC||K to 11||1915|
|9||St. George's School of Montreal||Montreal, QC||K to 11||1930|
|10||College Prep International||Montreal, QC||5 to 12||1944|
It's reasonable to consider having an entry in Wikipedia as a credible mark of influence. Schools in Montreal are ranked below on the basis of how many of their graduates have Wikipedia entries. Granted that this is a simplistic measure of anyone's contribution to society, and any list that purports to rank schools' based on a factor like this has many limitations.
|1||Bishop's College School||Sherbrooke, QC||7 to 12||12|
|2||Study||Westmount, QC||K to 11||8|
|3||Selwyn House School||Westmount, QC||K to 11||6|
|4||West Island College (Montreal)||Montreal (DDO), QC||7 to 11||4|
|5||Séminaire Marie-Reine-du-Clergé||Métabetchouan-Lac-à-la-Croix, QC||7 to 11||4|
|6||Kuper Academy||Kirkland, QC||PS to 11||2|
|7||Sacred Heart School of Montreal||Montreal, QC||7 to 12||2|
|8||Lower Canada College||Montreal, QC||K to 12||2|
|9||Pensionnat du Saint-Nom-de-Marie||Montreal, QC||7 to 11||2|